The Israeli Proposal: Reciprocal Positive Attitudes Needed More than Exchanging Lands

Hasan Yahya, Michigan, USA

According to [EPA] A new Israeli (non-governmental) proposal allows Israel to annex Jewish settlements in the West Bank in exchange for equal amounts of territory. What’s new in this proposal, if it dances around on illegal grounds.   The plan, drafted in part by ex-military and intelligence officials, includes land swaps and no right of return.

A group of about 40 people prominent Israelis, worked on the project, including former high-ranking military and intelligence officials, has unveiled an “Israeli peace initiative” which it hopes will prod their government towards a deal with the Palestinian Authority – but few of the group’s proposals are new, and several have been rejected in the past by Israeli and Palestinian leaders. “The key principle of all regional peace agreements shall be Israeli withdrawals, guaranteed security, normal relations, and an end to all conflicts,” the proposal states. .(

The plan, calls for Israel to withdraw to 1967 borders, with a series of swaps allowing it to annex major Jewish settlements in the West Bank. It would not provide a right of return for Palestinian refugees, though they would receive financial compensation; and it calls for normalized relations between Israel and Arab states.

Under the new proposal, Israel would be allowed to permanently annex parts of the West Bank, in exchange for equal amounts of Israeli territory ceded to the Palestinian state. The plan would allow Israel to swap up to seven per cent of the West Bank’s area, less than the 10.6 per cent that former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert in 2008.

  For Palestinians, a State means a sustainable way of economic, social, and political aspects of life of the people. Exchanging land by land is misdemeanant to the rights of Palestinians who still believe that the Land of Palestine is theirs. No one hungry person may  accept 20% of the loaf he was once owned. This historical fact , shows that Jews in Palestine despite the steady arrival in Palestine of Jewish colonists after 1882 until the few weeks preceding the establishment of Israel in 1948 was there ever Jewish population other than a huge Arab majority. For example, the Jewish population in 1931 was only 174,606 against a total of 1,033,314.” Edward Said, “The Question of Palestine.”. Converting this to percentage, it comes to 16.89%.

Early Jews settlers were more wise than today’s Israelis, for example, “An article by Yitzhak Epstein, published in Hashiloah in 1907…called for a new Zionist policy towards the Arabs after 30 years of settlement activity…Like Ahad-Ha’am in 1891, Epstein claims that no good land is vacant, so Jewish settlement meant Arab dispossession…Epstein’s solution to the problem, so that a new “Jewish question” may be avoided, is the creation of a bi-national, non-exclusive program of settlement and development. Purchasing land should not involve the dispossession of poor sharecroppers. It should mean creating a joint farming community, where the Arabs will enjoy modern technology. Schools, hospitals and libraries should be non-exclusivist and education bilingual…The vision of non-exclusivist, peaceful cooperation to replace the practice of dispossession found few takers. Epstein was maligned and scorned for his faintheartedness.” Israeli author, Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi, “Original Sins.”(

While  J Street, the US-based pro-Israel lobby, was quick to praise the plan as a “bold move.” unfortunately, AIPAC, at Washington is not helping in that regard. It insists on disunity between Palestinians is hurting both Israeli and Palestinian sides. In it latest strategy, AIPAC’s all over Capitol Hill, unlike J. Street, has begun a lobbying campaign stressing the “no partner” line. Which as a result encouraging efforts widening the gap between Palestinian factions, Such a strategy was made to  convince the US congress that there simply are no Palestinians fit to negotiate with Israel.

The proposal may be expected to be in the agenda when Netanyahu visit to Washington next Spring, for a series of meetings and public appearances. The release comes a day after US president Barack Obama met in Washington with Israeli president Shimon Peres. “With the winds of change blowing through the Arab world, it’s more urgent than ever that we try to seize the opportunity to create a peaceful solution between the Palestinians and the Israelis,” Obama said.

The new proposal did not mention any cooperating communities, or modern technological schools to promote positive attitude necessary for cultural normalization.

What is needed is an exchanged positive attitude toward each other, Palestinians and Israelis,  rather than exchanging land. While land remains necessary for people to reside on, the spirit of tolerance and positive attitudes are more needed.

What Palestinians want is to regain dignity  and pride as Palestinians, Israel never accepted the rights for Palestinians, or showing sympathy with suffering Palestinians through the years. Initiatives of positive attitude is releasing the 11,000 prisoners from Israeli jails and returning the illegally confiscated land. The most important, however, is helping out, making the State of Palestine liable and sustainable, through land, air, and sea. (Gaza and the West Bank together constitute 22 per cent of historic Palestine. In fact,   the West Bank is landlocked with Gaza’s Mediterranean port being the Palestinians’ only outlet to the world. Without Gaza, the West Bank is not a country but a walled-in ghetto.

About the issue remaining of refugees of 1948. It may be difficult, but both refugees of 1948 or 1967, should have the right to return to the newly established State of Palestine.  This issue was included in the  Arab peace initiative which calls for a “just solution” to the refugee problem, based on United Nations resolution 194, which enshrines a Palestinian right of return. This issue can be solved, by establishing fund to compensate sufferings and properties of 1948 refugees as well as 1967.

In conclusion, no proposal, in my opinion,  for peace would be acceptable without connected (1967 borders), Gaza Strip with the West Bank (Bridges or underground tunnel) , a port on the red Sea with access to the Port of Eilat,  and compensation for the refugees from 1948 and 1967. In addition to releasing Palestinian prisoners as a good well gesture. As far as these conditions not fulfilled, The Israeli proposal remains short to satisfy common wish of both Israelis and Palestinians inspiration to live in peace. (1052 words)

About Arab American Encyclopedia-USA - Hasan Yahya

HASAN YAHYA was born at a small village called Majdal-YaFa (Majdal Sadiq) in Mandate Palestine (1944). He migrated as a refugee to Mes-ha, a village east of Kufr Qasim, west of Nablus (in the West Bank), then moved with his family to Zarka, 25 km north of Amman – Jordan. He finished the high school at Zarka Secondary School, 1963. He was appointed as a teacher in the same year. Studied Law first at Damascus University, then B.A from Lebanon University in Arabic literature and Eastern Cultures (1975). He moved to Kuwait. Where he got married in 1967. He was working at Kuwait Television, taught at bilingual School, and Kuwait University. In 1982, Hasan left to the United States to continue his education at Michigan State University. He got the Master Degree in 1983, the Ph.D degree in 1988 in Education (Psychology of Administration ). In 1991, He obtained his post degree in Social research, the result was a second Ph.D degree in Comparative sociology-Social Psychology. He was the only Arab student who enrolled ever to pursue two simultaneous Ph.D programs from Michigan State University and fulfill their requirements perfectly. Professor Yahya employment history began as a supervisor of a joint project to rehabilitate Youth (inmates out of prison) by Michigan State University and Intermediate School Districts. Worked also as a Teacher Assistant and lecturer in the same university. He was offered a position at Lansing Community College as well as Jackson Community College where he was assistant professor, then associate professor, then full professor (1991-2006). He taught Sociology, psychology, education, criminology and research methods. He supervised 19 Master and Ph.D candidates on various personal, economic psychological and social development topics. Professor Yahya published Hundreds (1000 Plus on this site) of articles and research reports in local, regional, and international journals. His interest covers local, regional and global conflicts. He also authored, translated, edited and published over 280 plus books in several languages, in almost all fields especial education, sociology and psychology. These books can be found on Amazon and Kindle. He also, was a visiting professor at Eastern Michigan University to give Research Methods and Conflict Management courses. Prof. Yahya accepted an offer to join Zayed University Faculty Team in 1998, then he served as the Head of Education and Psychology Department at Ajman University of Science and Technology 2001-04. Dr. Yahya established several institutes in Diaspora, the Arab American Encyclopedia, Ihyaa al Turath al Arabi Project, (Revival of Arab Heritage in Diaspora.Recently he was nominated for honorary committee member for the Union of Arab and Muslim Writers in America. He was affiliated with sociological associations and was a member of the Association of Muslim Social Scientists (AMSS) at USA. Social Activities and Community Participation: Dr. Yahya was a national figure on Diversity and Islamic Issues in the United States, with special attention to Race Relations and Psychology of Assimilation (generations 1,2 &3). He was invited as a public speaker to many TV shows and interviews in many countries. His philosophy includes enhancing knowledge to appreciate the others, and to compromise with others in order to live peacefully with others. This philosophy was the backgrounds of his theory, called “ Theory C. of Conflict Management”. And developed later to a Science of Cultural Normalization under the title: “Crescentology. The results of such theory will lead to world peace depends on a global Knowledge, Understanding, appreciation, and Compromising (KUAC)” Recently Prof. Yahya started "Publish your book FREE Project", to serve young Arab Writers. Dr. Yahya accepted the offer to be the chief editor of the International Humanities Studies Journal -I-H-S-Jerusalem, since July 2014. (Revised Sept. 2014) ولد الدكتور حسن عبدالقادر يحيى في مجدل يابا من أعمال يافا – فلسطين عام 1944. تلقى علومه الابتدائية في مدرسة بديا الأميرية في الضفة الغربية أيام احتوائها ضمن المملكة الأدردنية الهاشمية وتخرج في جامعة بيروت حاملاً الإجازة في اللغة العربية وآدابها، ودبلوم التأهيل التربوي من كلية القديس يوسف بلبنان، ودبلوم الدراسات العليا (الماجستير) ودكتوراة في الإدارة التربوية من جامعة ولاية ميشيغان بالولايات المتحدة عام 1988، وشهادة الدكتوراه في علم الاجتماع المقارن من الجامعة نفسها عام 1991. عمل في التدريس والصحافة الأدبية. أديب وشاعر وقاص ، ,كما عمل في تلفزيون الكويت الرسمي كمعد ومنسق برامج ثم اتجه إلى الكتابة والتأليف في علوم كثيرة تخص علمي النفس والاجتماع والتنمية البشرية ، والتغير الاجتماعي والسكان وألف ونشر العديد من المقالات (1000 +) والكتب باللغتين العربية والإنجليزية (أكثر من 330 كتابا) ، منها ست مجموعات قصصية وست كتب للأطفال ، وأربع دواوين شعرية باللغتين أيضا. وعدد من كتب التراث في الشعر والأدب والأخلاق الإسلامية والتربية والأديان . وهو الآن أستاذ متقاعد في جامعة ولاية ميشيغان. . وكان عضوا سابقا في جمعية العلماء المسلمين في أمريكا . وجمعية علماء الاجتماع الأمريكية - ميشيغان، وهو مؤسس الموسوعة العربية الأمريكية في الولايات المتحدة ضمن مشروع إحياء التراث العربي في بلاد المهجرز كما تم ترشيحه مؤخرا ليكون عضو مجلس التحرير لمجلة الدراسات الإنسانية العالمية. وقد قبل أن يتسلم رئاسة تحريرها اعتبارا من نهاية يونيو 2014 His email: Thank you!
This entry was posted in Middle East Politics, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to The Israeli Proposal: Reciprocal Positive Attitudes Needed More than Exchanging Lands

  1. Pingback: Dr. Yahya Archive: April 2011 من أرشيف الدكتور يحيى : أبريل |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s